Growing a business to regenerate nature - Sally Gouldstone
Dr Sally Gouldstone, Founder of Seilich, a wildlife friendly herbal tea and skincare company near Pathhead, talks with host Osbert Lancaster.
Listen to hear how botanist Sally became so frustrated with traditional nature conservation projects that she decided to try a different approach – and created a new kind of business that thrives when nature thrives.
Sally reflects on journey that’s been both tough and rewarding, talking about:
- how “natural” products aren’t always good for nature
- how a genuinely wildlife friendly business approach regenerates nature
- why luxury products should be held to the highest environmental standards
- advice and lessons for other green businesses looking for investment and support
- how other farmers and landowners can get involved with this approach
- and much more…
Changing Climate, Changing Midlothian explores what the climate and nature emergency means with people living and working in the county. Their reflections will help inform discussions as cross sector representatives and community leaders meet in October to agree a new Single Midlothian Plan setting collective outcomes and actions for the next three years.
Changing Climate, Changing Midlothian is produced for the Midlothian Community Planning Climate Emergency Group by Thrivable Scotland, and is kindly supported by Midlothian Climate Action Hub, Midlothian Community Planning and Midlothian Energy Ltd.
Find out more about:
- Seilich, meadow grown skincare
- Wildlife Friendly Enterprise Network | WFEN
- This podcast and the Midlothian Community Planning Partnership
Thrivable Scotland helps changemakers engage their colleagues, communities and stakeholders to solve challenges today while building capacity to thrive in an unpredictable future.
Transcript
And it's so important that more businesses do start to really, really
2
:understand the impact that they're having.
3
:But not just the impact they're
having, the opportunity for
4
:them to make a difference.
5
:And I don't believe that we need to look
to the government , it's in our hands
6
:to make change in a lot of ways, and a
business that's built around that is just
7
:a fantastic way to, to make change happen.
8
:Speaker: I'm Osbert Lancaster, and
this is Changing Climate, Changing
9
:Midlothian, where we explore what the
climate and nature emergency means with
10
:people living and working in the county.
11
:In this episode, I'm talking with Dr.
12
:Sally Gouldstone, founder of
Seillich, a wildlife friendly
13
:herbal tea and skincare company.
14
:I walked with Sally at her
Wildflower Meadow, near Pathhead.
15
:I started by asking Sally how
she came to set up the business.
16
:Sally: my background was
in nature conservation.
17
:I worked in science for about 20 years,
became a botanist, I was working at
18
:the Botanic Gardens in Edinburgh.
19
:Fantastic job.
20
:But it was always really frustrating
because you get to a point in
21
:a project where you kind of
knew how to solve the problem.
22
:So whether you were working on a rare
species, and you'd finally worked out
23
:what was constraining the population
and you were ready to do something about
24
:it, and then the funding would run out,
or it would be a habitat creation or
25
:restoration project, and you'd finally
get to a point where you're starting to
26
:see change and the funding would run out.
27
:And you were constantly having to move
onto new and new projects, which is
28
:exciting, but it was really frustrating.
29
:So I was always kind of thinking about an
alternative funding model for conservation
30
:work where you could constantly drip
feed money into a project and it would
31
:have this continuity where you would
see real change for the long term.
32
:So when I had a baby, it was an
opportunity to make big changes in my
33
:life and I decided I was gonna start
a business that would drip feed its
34
:profits into some kind of habitat
restoration conservation project.
35
:Osbert: Right.
36
:Sally: And so that's how this started
and decided to work on Wildflower Meadows
37
:as a habitat that I was creating because
they're one of the most hopeful habitats.
38
:They're really quick to appear.
39
:They attract so much biodiversity,
they sink lots of carbon.
40
:And in terms of natural
timescales, they're doing all
41
:this really, really quickly.
42
:Osbert: Yeah.
43
:Sally: Which is amazing.
44
:And then I decided I was going to
harvest something from the Meadows,
45
:make them into something and sell that.
46
:Osbert: Right.
47
:So that was the model was to,
48
:Sally: yeah.
49
:Osbert: Make something that was in and
of itself was doing nature conservation
50
:and making money, money rather than what
a lot of businesses and organisations
51
:that want to support nature financially,
they'll like create a project doing
52
:something and then they'll donate some
of the profits to fund something else.
53
:We're just trying to do
everything in one package.
54
:Sally: That's right.
55
:Osbert: In one place, one field.
56
:Sally: And, and we're also kind of
challenging the idea of where our
57
:natural products come from as well.
58
:And I've got this idea that our
natural product should be good for
59
:nature, where nature is being used
as a marketing tool to sell products.
60
:And you see this in the
skincare market, for example.
61
:We've got these beautiful pictures
of nature all over the packaging,
62
:but nature isn't actually seeing
any of the benefits of that.
63
:It's just been exploited.
64
:Yet we are led to believe that somehow
these natural products are, you know,
65
:really good for the natural world as well.
66
:Which they're not
67
:Osbert: we don't need to go into
great detail, but what, what an
68
:example of ways in which natural
products aren't actually helpful.
69
:Sally: So if we go through
this hedgerow here,
70
:Osbert: you carry on
71
:Sally: this headland, you'll
see exactly what I mean.
72
:So behind us we've got our
amazing wildfire meadow.
73
:Supports loads and loads of biodiversity.
74
:So absolutely teaming with life.
75
:Yet from it we can harvest our
ingredients then, support this space
76
:as well as making beautiful products.
77
:Yeah.
78
:On the other side of here, you have
got miles and miles and miles of
79
:a crop, single species supports
very, very limited biodiversity.
80
:The soil is ploughed every year.
81
:Well, the carbon that was
stored in that soil is a emitted
82
:back into the atmosphere.
83
:And most of our natural products,
that's the way they're grown.
84
:Osbert: Right.
85
:Sally: And yet we see on the package
86
:Osbert: so lavender or whatever it is
87
:Sally: they're
88
:Osbert: Exactly.
89
:Sally: It's just another,
90
:Osbert: another monoculture.
91
:Sally: Another monoculture.
92
:Osbert: Right.
93
:Sally: Why is that good for nature?
94
:It's not good for nature.
95
:And then sometimes you'll see, the
companies that are producing these
96
:products, you know, they'll say, oh,
lavender supports so much biodiversity.
97
:But of course they're harvesting that
crop at the very point that it is
98
:producing all that nectar and pollen.
99
:Osbert: Oh, yes.
100
:Right.
101
:Sally: So why is that good for nature?
102
:Yeah.
103
:We just sold this story very clever
marketing teams lead us to believe
104
:that they're good for nature.
105
:Osbert: Yeah.
106
:Sally: Which of course they're not.
107
:So we are trying to kind of challenge
that in the industry as well and
108
:say, look, maybe , when we are using
nature as a marketing tool, maybe
109
:we need to be giving back to nature.
110
:So here we are.
111
:Osbert: Right?
112
:Sally: And in the summer when you're
in the meadow, you can hear the
113
:buzz of all the pollinating insects.
114
:Osbert: I'm sure.
115
:Sally: It's like somebody's left the
static on the television, then you
116
:come through here and it's silent.
117
:Osbert: So a field of barley, wheat?
118
:Sally: Yeah, it was wheat.
119
:Wheat.
120
:And it just goes on and on for, yeah.
121
:And you know, it's not, I'm
not blaming farmers here.
122
:They do an amazing job of feeding us.
123
:Yeah.
124
:But it just shows the direct comparison.
125
:Osbert: Sure.
126
:Sally: And this is what most of
our landscape is dedicated to
127
:now, especially in this area.
128
:Osbert: So you had this vision of
meadows doing good stuff for nature,
129
:being able to harvest from that in
a way which is not destroying what
130
:you're trying to save and create.
131
:Yeah.
132
:Sally: Yeah.
133
:Osbert: How's it working out?
134
:Sally: Financially it's tough.
135
:A product-based business.
136
:I hadn't realised, how much you
needed to invest in a product based
137
:business 'cause you've obviously got to
produce something before you sell it.
138
:So you are always chasing
the next stage up.
139
:So every time you want to grow bigger,
you've got to invest more to get there.
140
:And, I was completely naive.
141
:I had no idea about running a
business at all when I started
142
:coming from the science world.
143
:So that has been a real learning curve.
144
:In terms of consumer interest in this
idea of products that are good for
145
:nature and growing in different ways.
146
:There's huge, huge interest at the moment.
147
:Osbert: Mm-hmm.
148
:Sally: It's definitely a growing market.
149
:People are questioning where their
ingredients come from, so I definitely
150
:think there's room for growth
there, but in terms of support for
151
:businesses that are trying to do
something good, it's very limited.
152
:If you're not a charity, if you're
not a social enterprise, if you
153
:are a genuine business that's
trying to do something good.
154
:There's no support for that really.
155
:Osbert: Ah-huh.
156
:Would you describe what you're doing
as being a regenerative business?
157
:Is that a phrase that you would use
158
:Sally: Regenerative definitely fits.
159
:There's this concept of nature positivity.
160
:Mm-hmm.
161
:Nature positive business.
162
:That's a good fit as well.
163
:Hearing recently about this
idea of more than profit Uhhuh
164
:Osbert: that
165
:Sally: I quite like as well.
166
:Um, but in terms of the way we are
growing, 'cause regenerative of course
167
:applies to a method of farming as well.
168
:Osbert: Yes.
169
:Sally: I think what we're doing
is it's regenerative farming.
170
:We're putting back into the land,
we're reinvesting in the land.
171
:So I think that's quite a good term.
172
:That captures both the business model
and the, the growing model as well.
173
:Osbert: So , you said it was
difficult to find any support
174
:for growing your business.
175
:Mm-hmm.
176
:Do you think that was because
support is difficult to find anyway?
177
:Or was it because those who
could have supported you, didn't
178
:understand what you're trying to
do and didn't see the vision or?
179
:Sally: The issue was that I was up
against businesses that needed less
180
:investment for the same financial gain.
181
:So to, to create that meadow, for example,
was really expensive and it was, you know,
182
:a lot of people say that's unnecessary.
183
:How much ingredient do you need to grow?
184
:You need the small amount of land.
185
:You can grow that intensively over a much
smaller period of time, smaller amount of
186
:land, and get the same financial outcome.
187
:Why would we invest in something,
be because perhaps those additional
188
:gains in terms of the biodiversity
gains, the, carbon sunk, aren't
189
:accounted for In business models
particularly, we, we are still seeing.
190
:A successful business in terms of how
much profit it's making financially.
191
:And I think if we could look at businesses
more holistically and think about
192
:these ecosystem services that they're
providing to humanity and capture that
193
:Osbert: mm-hmm.
194
:Sally: Then I think investible businesses
that the whole framework would shift.
195
:Osbert: so a tough space to be,
196
:Sally: it is a tough space.
197
:But we went through the Scottish
Edge process, which is, um, kind
198
:of competition based business
funding for young businesses.
199
:And they, they could see the
value in what we were doing,
200
:and they had a special category.
201
:Yeah.
202
:So we were enable, we were able
to get some funding through that.
203
:Osbert: Great.
204
:Sally: And then we're going through,
ventures labs at the moment, which
205
:again, helps businesses for good
to find funding that wouldn't
206
:otherwise be available to them.
207
:So I think there's
starting to be these little
208
:Osbert: mm-hmm.
209
:Sally: Chinks where you can
get that support that you need.
210
:For me, the whole reason for
running the business is to create
211
:and manage spaces for nature.
212
:It's not actually to
produce these products.
213
:Yes.
214
:They're almost a byproduct
of what I'm doing.
215
:So, it's not like sustainability is
a bolt bolt-on to the business model.
216
:Osbert: Yeah.
217
:So you want to create spaces
for nature, in order to do
218
:that, has to work financially.
219
:Sally: Yeah.
220
:There is quite, kind of a dangerous
message in what I'm doing though
221
:in, and that I'm almost suggesting
that nature can pay its own way.
222
:And I don't necessarily that think that's
true if we kind of look globally, I think
223
:we definitely need to invest in nature
rather than saying, oh, well it should
224
:be, should be able to pay for itself.
225
:Osbert: Yeah.
226
:Stand its own two feet.
227
:Sally: Yes.
228
:Osbert: Yeah.
229
:Yes.
230
:Sally: I think we perhaps need to put
a bit back before we get to that stage.
231
:Osbert: Yeah.
232
:Sally: But I do want to demonstrate
that once you have put back then
233
:what it provides to us in return
is financially worth something.
234
:the Wildlife Friendly Enterprise Network
started as an American organisation
235
:and they certify, businesses that
their sole kind of reason for being
236
:really is nature conservation.
237
:And it, and it was just so well
aligned with what we're doing and there
238
:seemed to be a lot of other businesses
that were started by people from
239
:the conservation sector like myself.
240
:So I kind of wanted to
be part of that network.
241
:And then I found out that they had the
certification system for the products as
242
:well, which was just such a great fit.
243
:And they've been hugely supportive to us.
244
:So we managed to get a stand down at
Chelsea Flower Show this year, and
245
:Christine, who runs the Wildlife Friendly
Enterprise Network, came across and
246
:supported us at the stand, and to me
that's so valuable to have them there,
247
:them present, we're not just another
skincare brand saying we're sustainable.
248
:You know, we've got the head of the
enterprise network who's come over
249
:because she feels so strongly that
what we're doing is the real deal.
250
:Osbert: That's evidence of real
confidence in what you're doing.
251
:Sally: There's lots of people that are
growing their own ingredients, they
252
:might be growing in an organic way, which
is great, but they're not necessarily
253
:growing in a biodiverse way, and they're
not completing the loop by feeding those
254
:profits back into that same land and
managing it for biodiversity necessarily.
255
:There is such pressure on our food system
to, you know, feed, feed the world.
256
:Yeah.
257
:So, I, I don't think it's fair
to place the same expectations on
258
:the food system that we have on.
259
:I mean, I'm really producing
luxury products, they're
260
:not essential to human life.
261
:And I think this is where we should
raise our expectations and and
262
:demand more from those producers.
263
:Osbert: So you're arguing like, if it
is a luxury, it needs to be done to a
264
:higher standard than, than for essentials.
265
:Sally: I really think so.
266
:Osbert: Yeah.
267
:This may be a bit, a bit controversial
but the argument around, should
268
:we be eating meat because of the
269
:Sally: Yeah.
270
:Osbert: Emissions from meat.
271
:You may, may argue, well,
okay, if we're gonna have meat,
272
:that is a luxury, therefore
273
:Sally: Yeah.
274
:Osbert: You need to make
it amazingly regenerative.
275
:Sally: And it can be because grazers are
such an important part of our ecosystems.
276
:Wildflower Meadows, for example,
this 97% loss of Wildflower
277
:Meadows since the 1930s, they
weren't a kind of natural habitat.
278
:If you left a wildflower meadow to its
own devices, it would eventually become
279
:shrubland and then Woodland, you know, we
are constantly pushing succession back to
280
:the beginning with a wildflower meadow.
281
:And that's how we ended up with
so many of them because they
282
:were part of this farming system.
283
:Osbert: Yeah.
284
:I dunno about in Scotland, but
certainly in parts of England,
285
:many of the water meadows were
actually physically like created
286
:Sally: Exactly.
287
:Osbert: And managed really, really closely
with like managing water levels and stuff.
288
:That's
289
:Sally: right.
290
:Osbert: For grazing and for hay.
291
:Sally: That's right.
292
:Osbert: Yeah.
293
:Sally: They're hugely bio diverse now.
294
:Osbert: Completely unnatural.
295
:Sally: Yeah.
296
:They completely unnatural.
297
:And I find it really interesting that
we're now trying to put them back.
298
:Osbert: Mm.
299
:Sally: And that's why they're
kind of quite hopeful habitats
300
:wild flower meadows, 'cause they
were created by man to begin with.
301
:They supported these hugely
high levels of biodiversity.
302
:Osbert: Yeah.
303
:Sally: To the extent that now
we are losing them, we actually
304
:have to put them back again.
305
:Osbert: Any thoughts you might have
for other people who were in a similar
306
:position to you who were looking to create
a business, which was trying to do the
307
:right thing for the environment, for
biodiversity, what would your advice be?
308
:Sally: I think now's a really good
time to go for it, to be honest.
309
:I think the market's there, I
think the public are behind it.
310
:They, they want these products that
are good for the environment, you
311
:know, that people are very aware of
their own impact on the environment.
312
:People are looking for them.
313
:So I think there's
definitely a market there.
314
:And then we've talked about
funding, touched on that, and I
315
:think there are more doors opening
to support businesses like that.
316
:So I think now is such a
great time to just go for it.
317
:Osbert: Mm-hmm.
318
:Sally: And it's so important that more
businesses do start to really, really
319
:understand the impact that they're
having, but not just the impact.
320
:They're having the opportunity for
them to make a difference and I don't
321
:believe that we need to look to the
government and, and it's all their fault
322
:that all these disasters are happening.
323
:I know it's in our, it's in our hands
to make change in a lot of ways, and a
324
:business that's built around that is just
a fantastic way to, to make change happen.
325
:Osbert: Why so important right now?
326
:Sally: In terms of kind of the, the
biodiversity crisis, climate change,
327
:pollution, things are getting worse, you
know, let's be perfectly honest, and
328
:for that reason, I believe there's no
better time the now to, to start reining
329
:that back in and turning that tide.
330
:Osbert: You talked a bit about
the funding stuff , some of
331
:the challenges around that.
332
:Are there things that, from your
experience that, the local, local
333
:authorities, other organisations,
both public and private sector,
334
:could they be working differently?
335
:Could they be supporting organisations
like businesses that are trying to
336
:do the right things differently?
337
:Sally: In Midlothian, the local Business
Gateway has been hugely supportive
338
:of what I'm doing and every time I've
gone to them say, I need help with
339
:this, they have found that support,
not necessarily funding as an example.
340
:Sure.
341
:I want to run an advertising campaign.
342
:I don't have the funds to go to a big,
ad agency to do that for me, but they've
343
:found an ad agency who's willing to
give some time to help me to launch
344
:that ad campaign , show me how to do it.
345
:Osbert: That is wonderful.
346
:Sally: Bits of support like
that are fantastic, I must say.
347
:It's not all that obvious
that that support is there.
348
:You have to make yourself
known, you have to ask for it.
349
:But if you do that and you keep
pushing, the support is there.
350
:I think Midlothian is actually
a really positive place to be
351
:working and, and making change.
352
:I think what's really nice about
Midlothian is that you do have this
353
:much more personal approach and that
there's someone that you go to talk to.
354
:Osbert: Yeah.
355
:Sally: And you say, this is
the particular situation.
356
:It's not a box ticking,
fill this form out.
357
:Well, I mean, there are forms
358
:Osbert: obviously.
359
:Sally: But you have that
more personal approach.
360
:And there's something very
special in that as well.
361
:Osbert: So we just walked around
some big fields full of, well,
362
:stubble, monoculture, stubble.
363
:We're now coming back to
your wildflower meadow.
364
:We are past the peak of the
peak, peak of flowering season,
365
:but what are we looking at here?
366
:What's, what's happening?
367
:So
368
:Sally: about six years ago,
this was an arable field, like
369
:those we've just walked through.
370
:So it had received an awful lot
of, herbicides and pesticides to
371
:enable it to be very productive.
372
:So when we inherited it, biodiversity
levels were very, very low.
373
:Indeed.
374
:If you dug down into the soil,
there were no worms, for example.
375
:We then, seeded it well with a wildflower
mixture and this is the result.
376
:Osbert: Yeah.
377
:Sally: So we've now got, a really
floristically diverse meadow.
378
:So we've got grasses, we've got what
we would call flowers growing amongst
379
:that huge numbers of invertebrates.
380
:So you've got all your pollinating
insects, got beetles, lots of spiders,
381
:and then of course you get the birds
that come in to eat all those things.
382
:The swallow population here in the
summer is just absolutely phenomenal.
383
:It's been amazing to see
that increase over the years.
384
:And then of course you get all the
small mammals that come in, as well.
385
:So just the other day we found a little
hedgehog, in the meadow, which was lovely.
386
:Osbert: Right.
387
:Sally: They've got kind
of layer upon layer
388
:Osbert: Yeah.
389
:Sally: Of life that's
supporting each other.
390
:We've built up this incredible
ecosystem in a very short space of time,
391
:And we are really lucky here that
the landowner, the same family as
392
:owned this land for hundreds of
years, and they've maintained these
393
:wooded field boundaries mm-hmm.
394
:That go off into the wider countryside.
395
:Yeah.
396
:And they are incredible
connectivity corridors that have
397
:bought all this wildlife in.
398
:Osbert: Yeah.
399
:That's great.
400
:So what's next?
401
:Sally: My dream is that as our business
grows and our requirement for ingredients
402
:grows, we can reach out to farmers who are
looking to diversify and say, would you be
403
:prepared to create some wildflower meadow
and harvest some of these flowers for us?
404
:So we would then buy back at an
agreed rate, and therefore we'd be
405
:creating a market for wildlife friendly
ingredients, but an agreed buyback price.
406
:So the farmer wouldn't be making
this investment on a whim.
407
:They would know exactly what they could
get out of it at the end of the day.
408
:Mm-hmm.
409
:So we're working on that at the moment.
410
:Osbert: Mm-hmm.
411
:Excellent.
412
:That sounds exciting.
413
:can that interact with the various grant
schemes for conservation and wildlife
414
:friendly farming and that sort of thing?
415
:Sally: I think it definitely could.
416
:I think there's so much change
in that area at the moment.
417
:. And the way that I've built the business
is to ensure that there is this really
418
:positive gain at the end, and I would
hate for that to be constrained by
419
:some kind of government grant scheme.
420
:Osbert: Yeah.
421
:Sally: If we can create a financial
model that works without reliance
422
:on grants that benefits the farmer,
benefits us, benefits our customers,
423
:then I think that's the dream.
424
:Absolutely.
425
:And if there was a added
benefit of a grant, fantastic.
426
:But I don't necessarily want
to be constrained by that.
427
:Osbert: That makes a lot of sense.
428
:Sally: Yeah.
429
:Osbert: How much sort of input,
of time and energy to create
430
:this and to harvest it and so on?
431
:What works involved from the, from
the farmer's point of view, if they
432
:were gonna do something like this?
433
:Sally: So the initial investment is the
wild flower seed, which can be pricey.
434
:However, we offer a model where we
cut our hay, it's called the green
435
:hay cuts , when it's holding its
seed, and then we transport that
436
:onto the land where it sets its seed.
437
:So then you've got minimal cost
in terms of actually, setting up
438
:the, the meadow to begin with.
439
:And then of course you've got the costs
of harvest, as you do with, with any crop.
440
:We hand harvest a lot of this,
and then we've got little machines
441
:that go and cut other bits.
442
:Osbert: Right.
443
:Sally: So there's various different
ways of, of making it work.
444
:Osbert: That's very exciting.
445
:Thank you so much.
446
:And there you have it.
447
:You've been listening to Dr.
448
:Sally Goldstone, founder of Shali
on Changing Climate, changing
449
:Midlothian with me, Osbert Lancaster.
450
:I hope you found the conversation
as fascinating as I did.
